As working musicians, we’re all on limited budgets. Choosing between a Maschine or an MPC is difficult. For some genres, one might be preferable to the other. Even on some songs within the same genre, one might be used over the other and it can be difficult knowing where the most value is.
The Argument for Why Maschine is Better
The price of many basic Maschine setups on the market will be more affordable than an MPC or a sampler. Therefore, if it’s a case of you absolutely needing either a Maschine or an MPC today and you’re looking to save money, go with the Maschine.
By purchasing this DAW, you get a controller with it that will hook you up to any sequencing software and within seconds, you’ll be good to go to start creating beats. Designed similar to an Akai MPC, the Maschine controller features sixteen pads and back-lit buttons and is compatible with Native Instruments’ Traktor DJ software as well as Ableton Live and FL Studio.
Many people prefer the Maschine as a basic tool to create beats as it has a wealth of drum kit content and it’s quite versatile in that respect.
The Argument for Why an MPC is Better
The biggest advantage to an MPC for most people is that it is more versatile than a drum machine and does exceed the Maschine in different ways as well. It can be used as a live instrument, helping to make beats in real-time. It can give a more hands-on feel in crafting beats in the studio.
Better yet, it can be used to sample non-drum sounds, and help to craft different grooves and soundscapes off that. The workflow is oftentimes preferable as well, compared to the limitations of a drum machine. That said, Maschine can do these things in the same manner. The AKAI software employed with an MPC is generally thought to have better arrangement functions, which give it a slight advantage over Maschine on this front.
Pick and Choose where and when to use your Tools
These type of gear vs. gear articles are always going to be somewhat controversial because ultimately, it does depend on personal preference. There are some people that are going to inherently prefer one over the other.
What we say is to do what feels right for you and your music. For most people, the MPC software rates highly and they interpret it to be more versatile than Maschine. As a hardware tool, Maschine seems to be more popular than MPC, in the sense that using Maschine is closer to a standalone instrument that does not require fussing over any software to do its thing. MPC comes with its own wealth of synths but Maschine does have its fair share of selection and it can be paired with software like Kontact, Rector, and Guitar Rig quite easily.
It really comes down to what you’re using it for. Sometimes, Maschine wins out. Other times, MPC does.
No matter what you choose, amazing quality music has been produced by both. Don’t let anything hold back you or your creativity. Choose what appeals to you and go with that. Either of these are welcome additions to any musician’s arsenal.